How to Pick the Best Dog Toys: Because Your Dog Deserves More Than Chewed-Up Socks

Let’s be honest—your dog’s taste in toys isn’t exactly refined. One day it’s a squeaky dinosaur you paid good money for, the next it’s your expensive shoe. Picking the best dog toys is part art, part science, and part just accepting your dog is a bit of a goofball. But that’s why we love them. This guide will help you choose toys your dog actually wants to play with (instead of your socks), keep them safe, and maybe even make you feel like Dog Parent of the Year.

First things first: know your dog’s style.

Is your pup a destroyer of worlds who reduces plush toys to sad piles of fuzz in 30 seconds flat? Or are they more of a gentle nibbler who cradles a toy like a teddy bear at nap time? Tough chewers need durable rubber toys—think these tough toys designed to survive even the Hulk of canines. Meanwhile, softer plushies are perfect for cuddlers who want a snuggle buddy more than a battle opponent. Choose toys to match the chewing style, unless you enjoy vacuuming fluff daily.

Size matters, too.

A toy that’s too small can be a choking hazard, and one that’s too big might make your dog look at you like you just handed them homework. Pick a size-appropriate toy so they can actually carry it around and feel like the big dog on the block (even if they’re five pounds soaking wet). Manufacturers usually list sizing guides, so it pays to check instead of guessing. Pro tip? When in doubt, go a little larger—it’s safer and gives your dog more to gnaw on.

Variety is the spice of a dog’s life.

Imagine if you only had one TV channel forever. Boring, right? Same for your dog. Rotate different types of toys to keep them engaged. Squeakers, ropes, treat-dispensing puzzles, and balls all serve different needs. Some burn off energy, some satisfy natural chewing urges, and others make them work for their snacks like a little furry engineer. Check out our Top Toy Picks Here for ideas to mix things up.

Durability is where you get to feel like a smart shopper.

Don’t buy the dollar-store toy that lasts 10 minutes (unless you like spending more in the long run). Invest in well-reviewed, quality toys that hold up. Look for reinforced seams on plush toys, heavy-duty ropes, and non-toxic materials on rubber toys. It’s safer for your dog and easier on your wallet. We’ve rounded up the best bang-for-your-buck options on our Recommended Toys Page.

Safety always comes first.

Avoid toys with tiny parts that can be swallowed or strings that can unravel into gut-twisting nightmares. Check labels for non-toxic materials—your dog will absolutely chew on it, so make sure it won’t poison them. And while you’re at it, supervise play when you introduce new toys. Not only does this help you gauge if the toy is safe, but it also gives you an excuse to giggle at your dog discovering a new squeak for the first time.

Finally, don’t forget enrichment value.

Toys aren’t just for biting—they’re for keeping your dog’s brain busy so they don’t remodel your living room in your absence. Puzzle toys and treat dispensers are sanity-savers for you and keep your dog feeling like a genius. Boredom is the real enemy here, and the right toy is your secret weapon. We’ve highlighted some great enrichment toys here if you want to level up your dog’s playtime.

Ready to upgrade your dog’s toy collection?

Avoid the cheap fluff (literally) and pick toys that match their personality, chewing style, and size. It’s one of the easiest ways to show you care—and keep your shoes safe. Check out our full list of top-rated, pup-approved toys right here and get ready to see the tail wags of gratitude.