Who’s a Good Tool? A Surprisingly Useful FAQ on Dog Training Gear

Q: What’s the best leash for training a dog that pulls?

A no-pull harness paired with a 4–6 foot standard leash is the gold standard. Retractable leashes during training are basically chaos on a spring. Front-clip harnesses like the PetSafe Easy Walk get solid reviews for reducing pulling without choking your dog or your dreams. Bonus: they help you look like you’re in control, even when you’re not.
          

Q: Are shock collars safe for training my dog?

Only if you enjoy guilt, drama, and questionable long-term results. Most pros recommend positive reinforcement tools instead. Vibration or beep collars can be useful if your dog is hard of hearing (or just ignoring you), but old-school shock collars can create anxiety or aggression. TLDR: your dog isn’t a fence-jumping velociraptor. Start with treats and clickers.
          

Q: What’s a clicker and does it really work?

It’s a tiny plastic noise-maker that sounds like your dog just got the answer right on a game show. Clicker training uses marker-based reinforcement — you “click” when the dog does something right, then follow with a treat. It’s timing-based, fast, and works shockingly well. Even zoos use clickers on tigers, so yeah, your Goldendoodle can figure it out.
          

Q: Are treat-dispensing toys good for training?

Yes — if you like training without turning into a human vending machine. Toys like the Kong Wobbler or the PetSafe Busy Buddy make dogs work for the reward. This keeps their brain busy, energy channeled, and your shoes intact. Great for crate training, boredom busters, or rewarding calm behavior. Also hilarious to watch.
          

Q: Do training collars actually help stop barking?

Kind of — but context matters. Citronella spray collars are the least offensive and surprisingly effective for light barkers. Ultrasonic and vibration collars work for some dogs, and do absolutely nothing for others. If your dog barks at shadows and dust mites, you might need a trainer, not a gadget.
          

Q: What are the best treats for training?

Small, soft, and stinky. That’s the golden trio. Your dog isn’t doing calculus — they’re learning to sit and not launch at the mailman. Use treats they go feral for: freeze-dried liver, chicken bits, or commercial training treats like Zuke’s or Bil-Jac. If your dog would punch you in the knee for it, it’s a good training treat.
          

Q: What’s the best way to potty train a puppy?

Consistency, timing, and an ocean of paper towels. Crate training and bell training both work, but the real MVP is getting your pup on a potty schedule. Use enzyme sprays to clean up mistakes so your dog doesn’t think your carpet is a designated repeat zone. Also, celebrate every poop like it just won an Oscar.
          

Q: Are head halters safe and effective for training?

Yes — if used properly. Head halters like the Gentle Leader work like reins on a horse: they redirect your dog’s attention without relying on brute force. They’re great for strong pullers, but some dogs hate the feeling at first. Take time to desensitize them and pair it with positive reinforcement, not tug-of-war.
          

Q: What training gear do I need for a new puppy?

Start simple. You’ll need a treat pouch, clicker, short leash, soft harness, chew toys, and enough paper towels to wrap a small car. Add baby gates and a crate if you value sanity. Keep it positive, structured, and reward heavy. Also, accept that your socks are no longer safe.
          

Q: Can I train an older dog with the same products?

Absolutely. Old dogs can learn new tricks — they just might take a bit longer to stop rolling their eyes at you. Treats, clickers, and harnesses work on dogs of any age. Joint-friendly tools like ramps or softer treats might be needed, but mentally? They’re still sharp. Don’t count ‘em out — some senior dogs become obedience class legends.

Q: Are vibrating collars a good alternative to shock collars?

Yes — for many dogs, especially those who are sound-sensitive or deaf. Vibrating collars give a gentle nudge instead of pain, and can be used as a cue to redirect behavior, similar to a tap on the shoulder. Look for models with adjustable intensity and a “tone only” option. That said, they still require training — don’t expect a magic collar to teach manners without your involvement (or a pocket full of snacks).
          

Q: What’s the deal with snuffle mats — are they just fancy rugs?

Snuffle mats are basically brain gyms for dogs — layered fabric strips where you hide treats, and your dog has to sniff them out. Great for building focus, calming overactive pups, or just getting five minutes of peace while they root around like furry truffle pigs. Especially useful for indoor training reinforcement or dogs who need mental exercise without zoomies. Plus, they’re machine washable, unlike your actual rugs.